Why the record comes before the clean-up
The natural reaction to a newly delivered AOL mailbox is to change the password at once. Securing it is right, but doing it first has a cost: every change you make replaces the state the mailbox arrived in. If something later turns out not to match the listing, you would be describing it from memory.
The window for raising a problem with an order is limited and shown on your order page, so the record has to be quick. Ten calm minutes of looking and writing down, before touching any setting, usually covers it.
Where AOL shows the state of a mailbox
Two AOL pages hold most of what you need. The Account Security page lists the recovery phone numbers and email addresses, shows whether 2-Step Verification is on, and has the entries for app passwords and passkeys. The Recent activity page, according to AOL's help centre, can show up to three sections: devices or browsers that signed in recently, apps connected to the account, and recent account changes, which lists the last three password changes with an option to show all.
Note also what happened during the sign-in itself: whether the password was accepted, whether AOL asked for a verification code, and where it said the code was sent. That single step tells you a lot about whether the recovery details match the description.
A two-column record you can actually use
Keep the record in a private note with two columns. On the left, copy the exact lines of the listing you bought, such as the age it claimed, the recovery details it mentioned and how the login was described. On the right, write what you observed and the time you observed it.
Useful rows are the address itself, whether the password worked, whether a code was requested and where it went, each recovery entry, the 2-Step Verification state and method, any app passwords or passkeys, connected apps, and the most recent account changes. Write recovery entries in shortened form, such as the last few digits of a phone number, rather than copying them in full, and keep passwords and codes out of the note entirely. The record is for you and, if needed, for a dispute; it should never be posted anywhere public.
A worked example: matching the record to the listing
Suppose a hypothetical listing reads: older address, recovery email included, 2-step off. After delivery the buyer signs in, AOL asks for a code, and the code arrives at the included recovery email. The address and password match, and 2-Step Verification is off. The Account Security page, however, also shows a recovery phone entry the listing never mentioned and one app password named after a desktop mail program.
Now sort the rows. The address, the password, the recovery email and the 2-step state all match, so the core of the listing holds. The extra phone entry and the app password are clean-up items rather than mismatches: the listing did not claim they were absent, and the buyer can remove both. A material difference would look different, for example a code sent to a contact the buyer was never given, an address other than the one listed, or 2-step verification switched on with someone else's phone. Those rows are the ones to take to a dispute.
Change things in an order that keeps you in
Once the record is saved, start with recovery. AOL's instructions are to add your new phone or email first and only then remove the old entry, so a working route exists at every step. Next, set a new password.
Then deal with app passwords, which are easy to overlook. AOL states that an app password stays active even after the main account password is changed, and that the only way to invalidate one is to delete it. Remove any you did not create, sign out or remove entries you do not recognise on the Recent activity page, and remove an unfamiliar passkey. Finally, turn on 2-Step Verification with a method you hold. Add each change and its time to the bottom of your note.
When the record says stop
If the sign-in cannot be completed because the code goes to a contact you were not given, or the delivered address is not the one in the listing, stop there. Do not keep changing settings in the hope of working around it; your record of the unchanged state is the useful thing now. Keep the brand's own rules in view as well: AOL's terms say no account is transferable and the password must stay confidential, so follow AOL's terms for any mailbox you decide to keep.
Using the record on rStock
On rStock the mailbox details arrive as a delivery record on your order page after you pay from your balance. If your two-column note shows a material difference, open a dispute within the window shown on that page and describe the rows that differ; the store answers first, and a moderator can be called in when you cannot agree. rStock is an independent marketplace and is not affiliated with AOL. The easiest records come from listings that state what is set, so when you next compare AOL mailboxes on rStock, favour descriptions that name the recovery details and the login method.